You May Like
Rare Sesame Street Going Green Elmo Plush Toy Factory
$24.99
View Details
Rare Vintage Sesame Street Stuffed Animal Plush Lot - Sesame Street
$40.00
View Details
Ultra Rare 12” Big Bird Squishmallow SeaWorld Exclusive 2021 Sesame Street Plush
$24.99
View Details
Sesame Street Rosita Gund Plush 13" Stuffed Animal Yellow Bow Green 2014 RARE U
$77.21
View Details
Rare Vintage 1980s Sesame Street Purple Honker Plush
$25.00
View Details
Baby Zoe Plush Toy Sesame Street Vintage 2001 Brand New Rare
$35.95
View Details
New RARE Rosita Plush Sesame Street Place Rare 16" Green Spanish Girl
$64.95
View Details
Sesame Street Cookie Monster Purple 13" Plush Ultra RARE Stuffed Animal Toy wTAG
$29.99
View Details
Applause SNUFFLEUPAGUS Snuffy Puppet Sesame Street 9" Plush Stuffy Rare Vintage
$29.99
View Details
Vintage Sesame Street Zoe Plush Tyco 1996 RARE
$29.99
View Details
Abby Cadabby Sesame Street Plush Doll Gund 38" Jumbo Life Size 3 Feet RARE 2008
$29.99
View Details
RARE Vintage EDEN Muppets Kermit The Frog Full Body Collectible Sesame Street 22
$39.99
View Details
Sesame Street Hot Pink Cookie Monster Plush Toy - 10” RARE!
$34.95
View Details
NEW 15" Plush Abby Cadabby Ladybug Sesame Street Place Seaworld NWT RARE!
$42.00
View Details
Sesame Street Land Of Nod Letter Z Alphabet Pillow Plush RARE Crate & Barrel
$49.27
View Details
Sesame Street Ernie Stuffed Plush Baby Toy-Rare-Playskool-1991 (NEW)
$89.99
View Details
Rare SLIMEY the Worm Plush Exclusive Sesame Street Place Sea World NWT 2022
$65.00
View Details
Vintage 1995/97 Tyco Sesame Street Tickle Me Elmo Plush Talking Doll RARE Works
$19.99
View Details
Vintage Rare Knickerbocker Snuffleupagus Sesame Street Muppets Plush - 17" Long!
$44.99
View Details
Vtg 1970s Sesame Street Bert Knickerbocker Stuffed Plush Doll 15” Tall Rare
$15.25
View Details
RARE Sesamestrasse German Sesame Street Soccer Ball Plush Samson & Tiffy Germany
$49.99
View Details
Squishmallow ELMO Sesame Street Stuffed Plush 12" Kelly Toys SeaWorld Rare
$59.99
View Details
Rare Sesame Street Ringling Brothers Rosita Plush Bow Stuffed Animal Friend X4
$100.00
View Details
NWT Super RARE 05 20”Gray Elmo Sesame Street Tokyo Plush Hand Puppet Japan
$248.88
View Details
RARE VINTAGE 1984 Playskool ERNIE Plush Stuffed Doll Toy Sesame Street 10”
$34.99
View Details
Squishmallow ELMO Sesame Street Stuffed Plush 12" Kelly Toys SeaWorld Rare
$35.99
View Details
VTG Rare 2013 Gund Sesame Street Rosita Plush
$75.00
View Details
8" Rare Vintage Sesame Street Ernie Plush Magic Tyco 1996 Doll By Jim Henson
$8.00
View Details
Sesame Street Cookie Monster Green Plush Stuffed Animal Toy Factory 2022 Rare
$29.95
View Details
☆RARE☆ ~Sesame Street Cookie Monster Green 💚 Plush Stuffed Animal Toy Factory
$39.99
View Details
Sesame Street Elmo Pink 14” Stuffed Plush Animal Toy 2018 Jim Henson Rare HTF
$26.99
View Details
Sesame Street Ovejita Lamb Classic Character Collection Plush RARE 14 Inch READ
$227.49
View Details
Sesame Street Baby Natasha Beanbag Plush Doll by Tyco Rare 7 inch
$29.25
View Details
Sesame Street Little Bird Plush 8" Place Classic Character 2024 Rare HTF
$39.99
View Details
Cookie Monster Plush Sesame Place 19” RARE Sesame Street Toy
$17.15
View Details
SESAME STREET ERNIE MUPPETS 2003 vampire count dracula halloween plush rare 14"
$49.00
View Details
Vintage Toy 1983 PLAYSKOOL Sesame Street Plush 9" BIG BIRD Blue Shirt, Rare
$6.00
View Details
Rare Y2k 2006 Sesame Street Big Bird Limited Edition plush
$14.99
View Details
Plush Toy Of Elmo From Sesame Street Rare Suit
$40.00
View Details
Rare 2024 Cookie Monster 13" Plush Christmas Muppet Monster Sesame Street NWT!
$15.00
View Details
RARE Sesame Street REVERSIBLE COOKIE MONSTER PLUSH Sesame Place Bush Gardens
$29.95
View Details
RARE VTG Sesame Street Hasbro 7" Bert & Tyco 10" Ernie ~ Plush Toy Dolls
$8.99
View Details
Vintage 1983 Hasbro Preschool Sesame Street Honker Plush 8" Purple Muppet Rare!
$22.95
View Details
Kaws Sesame Street Red Elmo Plush Toy 20 inches UNIQLO Rare
$70.00
View Details
Vintage 2004 Elmo Red GIGGLE GABBER Sesame Street-Works-RARE-Storage Kept
$74.00
View Details
VTG Tyco Sesame Street Bean Bag Plush Lot Of 3 Betty Lou Zoe Big Bird 1997 Rare
$24.00
View Details
Sesame Street Plush Bus Characters Excellent Condition Rare Applause Vintage
$45.00
View Details
Big Bird Sesame Street Stuffed Animal 19” Plush Sesame Place RARE
$17.15
View Details
Sesame Place Plush Bunny Rabbit Fluffster Julia Autism Sesame Street Rare
$39.95
View Details
New 15" Slimey Worm Plush Oscar Grouch Pet Place Rare Sesame Street 2022
$63.49
View Details
Sesame Street Plush Bus Characters Excellent Condition Rare Applause Vintage
$34.99
View Details
Sesame Street 13" Big Bird Yellow Plush Stuffed Animal Vtg Collectible Rare
$17.09
View Details
RARE Sanrio Hello Kitty x SESAME STREET Cookie Monster & Elmo Small Plushies
$69.99
View Details
Sesame Street Christmas Stocking BIG BIRD Plush Kurt Adler Vintage 1998 Rare
$15.99
View Details
RARE NWT Vintage Sesame Street Bert Plush Stuffed Toy 14" Nanco 2003 NEW TAGS
$15.99
View Details
Rare Sesame Street Elmo Plush Purse Bag Tote Knapsack Jim Henson Zipper Closure
$23.99
View Details
New 12" Super Grover Plush Sesame Street Place Cape Helmet Cute Hero 2012 Rare
$16.15
View Details
Vintage 1986 Sesame Street Pull String Talking Big Bird Plush 22"Playskool Rare
$24.98
View Details
RARE: Full Brand New Sesame Street Plush Set of 4, 7”, Toy Factory
$59.99
View Details
RARE - Gund & FuRyu - Sesame Street - Grover - 12" Plush Doll - 2019 - NEW
$44.50
View Details
Vintage 1980 Sesame Street Oscar the Grouch Rattle Toy Plush 7" Gabriel Rare HTF
$14.99
View Details
RARE Sesame Street Zoe Plush Doll Backpack Keychain Clip NEW W/Tags NR
$9.44
View Details
Squishmallow Cookie Monster Sesame Street Plush 12" Kelly Toys SeaWorld Rare
$79.99
View Details
Choose One~RARE VINTAGE SESAME STREET PLUSH Acquired in Japan~-ship free
$33.00
View Details
Ovejita Sesame Street Classic Character Collection 14" Plush Spanish Lamb RARE
$279.00
View Details
☆RARE☆ ~Sesame Street Cookie Monster Green 💚 Plush Stuffed Animal Toy 2021~ ☆
$35.00
View Details
Squishmallow ELMO Sesame Street Stuffed Plush 12" Kelly Toys Rare
$22.87
View Details
Sesame Street Elmo Furchester PURPLE 7" Micro Plush Doll Soft Toy RARE Find New
$26.99
View Details
Sesame Street Honker Monster Plush Toy Vtg TYCO 1996 - Works - Rare HTF
$24.00
View Details
1997 • Tyco • Sesame Street The Cookie Monster Stuffed Plush • Jim Hanson RARE!
$14.95
View Details
Rare Rosita Sesame Street Gund Plush 13" Bow Mint Green Hispanic 2016
$74.99
View Details
1990s Vintage Applause Cookie Monster Plush - 6” - Sesame Street - Small rare
$14.96
View Details
Sesame Street Place Count Von Dracula 2012 Rare Plush Stuffed Toy Hard Eyes 18"
$79.99
View Details
BERT AND ERNIE APPLAUSE PLUSH SESAME STREET FELT FACE STITCHED MOUTH-RARE-
$24.00
View Details
Rare Vintage 1992 Sesame Street Elmo Plush By CHILD DIMENSION
$11.04
View Details
Sesame Street Elmo And Cookie Monster 8" Plush Animal By Toy Factory Rare NWT
$20.00
View Details
1995 Playskool Sesame Street Zoe Plush 14" Muppet Orange Stuffed Toy EUC Rare
$18.31
View Details
Vintage Rare Playskool Softies Sesame Street Baby Ernie Plush 12" Stuffed Doll
$15.00
View Details
Rare Purple Honker Bean Bag Plush Doll Sesame Street Tyco 8 inch
$23.74
View Details
Vintage Nanco Sesame Street Burt 14" Plush Stuffed Toy Used Condition Rare
$12.99
View Details
1980s Rare VTG Big Bird Sesame Street Plush Rattle Huggable Cookie Monster Tag
$12.99
View Details
Sesame Street Cookie Monster Plush Blue Zipper Purse 7" Vintage Kids FLAWS RARE
$13.46
View Details
Vintage Sesame Street Beans Elmo, Oscar and Zoe NEW In Box 1997 Tyco Rare
$14.99
View Details
1988 Sesame Street Big Bird Plush Christmas Stocking Hanger Holder Vintage -RARE
$12.85
View Details
Rare Vtg HONKERS Sesame Street Orange Stuffed Plush Doll Applause 6”
$19.99
View Details
Rare New 17" Purple Cat Elmo Plush Halloween Sesame Street 2024
$32.50
View Details
RARE Vintage Sesame Street Bert Plush Stuffed Toy 12" Nanco 2003 Tag Intact
$7.99
View Details
Sesame Street Cookie Monster Green 9" Plush Ultra RARE Stuffed Animal Toy NWT
$39.99
View Details
RARE 2010 Hasbro Sesame Street Talking Super Grover 40cm Plush Toy - WORKS
$37.65
View Details
RARE SESAME PLACE SESAME STREET 2006 COUNT VON COUNT PLUSH STUFFED TOY 18" VAMPI
$79.99
View Details
Gemmy Sesame Street ELMO Electronic Happy Birthday Plush Activated Decor *RARE*
$44.99
View Details
SSC: New 15" Slimey Worm Plush Oscar Grouch Pet Place Rare Sesame Street
$63.99
View Details
BNIP 2000 Sesame Street MY SIZE ELMO Fisher Price 93689 28" Talks-Sings RARE HTF
$68.00
View Details
Rare 11" Pose A Pal Cookie Monster Plush Sesame Street 2007 Posable Display
$11.50
View Details
1999 Kellogg's Sesame Street Mini Beans Oscar The Grouch SEALED RARE PLUSH TOY
$6.99
View Details
Sesame Street Count Pull Cord 10 Inch Plush Vintage Knickerbocker Rare NO Sound
$11.00
View Details
RARE Vintage Applause Big Bird Plush Ornament Knit Scarf Sesame Street Muppet
$10.99
View Details
Sesame Place Sesame Street The Count 18 Inch Plush 2011 Rare HTF Stuffed Toy PBS
$80.00
View Details
Cookie Monster Sesame Place Bush Gardens Plush Sea World Reversible Rare
$35.95
View Details
ULTRA RARE 12” Big Bird Squishmallow SeaWorld Exclusive 2021 Sesame Street Plush
$89.99
View Details